It's Valentine's Day! Casey and Cappie compete over who can come up with the most romantic gift. Also, Casey sets Katherine up with Rusty in an attempt to reconcile with her. Ashleigh is worried that new boyfriend Pete will turn out to be another Fisher, especially after Natalie implies that she and Pete are in a relationship. Evan attempts to bring out Rebecca's obscure romantic side with a special gift. Meanwhile, Calvin is worried that he and Grant are losing their spark, mainly after observing Grant's new beauty ritual.